Home/Videos/Why Invading Taiwan Could Be China's Biggest Mistake
Film companion
Why Invading Taiwan Could Be China's Biggest Mistake
What the film covers
This documentary asks whether China could invade Taiwan by starting with a battle China already lost, Kinmen in 1949, then comparing it with the Hainan landing of 1950 and the weather decision before D-Day. It then looks at the Taiwan Strait and landing beaches, China's new landing barges and assault ships, the Dec 2025 Pentagon report, Taiwan's reservists and HIMARS, a CSIS wargame, and a blockade or quarantine that needs no beach. It sets out what is documented and what is disputed. It does not predict a war.
- Kinmen 1949: why a force that crossed the water still could not stay ashore
- Hainan 1950: the landing that worked, and why it differed
- Taiwan Strait: shallow water, tides and few landing beaches
- Shuiqiao barges and the Type 076 assault ship: what China is building
- Pentagon report, Justice Mission 2025 and the 2027 goal
- Taiwan's Han Kuang drills, conscription and HIMARS
- CSIS wargame results, and the blockade or quarantine alternative
Chapters
- 0:00Will China Invade Taiwan? Kinmen 1949, Nine Thousand in Fishing Boats
- 1:06Guningtou Battle: Tanks and Aircraft Hit the Stranded Boats
- 2:26Why the 1949 Invasion Failed: Ye Fei's Written List
- 2:48Hainan 1950: Three Hundred Junks, and This Time It Worked
- 3:48Kinmen vs Hainan: Two Experiments, Which Fits Taiwan?
- 4:19D-Day 1944: Eisenhower, the Storm and the Weather Window
- 5:00Taiwan Strait Landing Beaches: Shallow Water, Few Places to Land
- 6:15Shuiqiao Landing Barges: The 800-Metre Floating Pier
- 7:54Justice Mission 2025: PLA Drills Around Taiwan
- 8:35Pentagon 2027 Goal: Why a Landing Is the Hardest Option
- 9:33Han Kuang 2026: Taiwan's Reservists and Conscription
- 10:27HIMARS and Minelayers: Taiwan's New Hardware
- 11:24CSIS Taiwan Wargame: Who Wins on Paper, and at What Cost
- 12:59Taiwan Blockade vs Quarantine: The Option With No Beach
- 14:55The 900 Who Surrendered at Kinmen
Questions the film answers
Could China invade Taiwan?
The Pentagon's report of 23 December 2025 says Xi's goal is for the PLA to have, by the end of 2027, the capabilities needed to prevail in a Taiwan conflict, and calls an island landing the most complex and difficult of its four options. Late in 2024 US defence officials said a short, sharp invasion by 2027 was not possible at that time. War on the Rocks reads the 2027 goal as a capabilities target, not a confirmed invasion plan.
What happened at Kinmen in 1949?
About 9,086 PLA soldiers crossed to Kinmen (Quemoy) in hundreds of wooden fishing boats and requisitioned junks on 24-25 October 1949. Boats drifted off the planned beach, were stranded as the tide fell, and Nationalist tanks, artillery and aircraft engaged them. Planners expected about 12,000 defenders; the garrison had reached over 40,000. The landing failed by 27 October, when about 900 PLA soldiers surrendered together.
Why did Hainan in 1950 succeed when Kinmen failed?
The PLA crossed in 318 junks in multiple waves after smaller probing landings from late February, local communist guerrillas already held much of the interior and guided the landing, and the Nationalist defence was disunited and short of supplies. Haikou fell on 23 April 1950.
How wide is the Taiwan Strait, and are there many landing beaches?
The strait is 126 km (78 mi) at its narrowest, with an average depth of 60 m. Ian Easton identified 14 beaches in 2017 that could be used as landing sites, and an INDSR analyst puts the workable sites in northern and western Taiwan at about 20. West-coast waters are shallow, so tide timing matters for larger civilian vessels.
What are the Shuiqiao landing barges?
A Naval War College CMSI note (March 2025) says the first set of three self-propelled barges linked into an 820-metre relocatable pier completed sea trials near Zhanjiang in early March 2025, with a second set under construction. The same note says they meet a logistics need but may create additional throughput problems moving equipment out of a landing area.
What did the CSIS wargame find?
CSIS's 'The First Battle of the Next War' (9 January 2023) ran 24 wargames of a 2026 invasion. In most, the US, Taiwan and Japan defeated a conventional amphibious invasion and Taiwan stayed autonomous, at high cost: dozens of ships, hundreds of aircraft and tens of thousands of servicemembers lost, and Taiwan's economy devastated. A wargame tests the designers' assumptions and is not a forecast.
Sources
- Battle of Guningtou
- Hainan Campaign
- Taipei Times, landing beaches
- Naval War College CMSI note on the Shuiqiao barges
- Taiwan Ministry of National Defense report
- War on the Rocks on the Dec 2025 Pentagon report
- USNI News, DoD officials on 2027
- USNI News, Han Kuang 2026
- CSIS, The First Battle of the Next War
- CSIS, how China could quarantine Taiwan
- NBC News, Takaichi remarks
The ebook
Where the ebook goes deeper
- Country files with forces, equipment and defence posture, each number carrying a source and a confidence stamp
- Head-to-head chapters on weapons systems
- Read the numbers behind the film at your own pace
Rank & Ledger: Global Military Power, Edition 2.0: 1,200 pages, 196 countries, 1,068 sources, a confidence rating on every number. One payment, no subscription.
See the ebook · $9.99→